Why RPO’s don’t solve all your Recruitment Programs

Why RPO’s don’t solve all your Recruitment Programs

Recruitment Process Outsourcing (RPO) became a fancy industry term for outsourcing recruitment about 20 years ago. RPO vendors boasted they could outperform your internal recruitment function and provide higher quality service, faster and at less cost. They incubated the notion that “recruitment” was not a “core” function of your business and that it made sense to outsource it. Hmmm…


I have been following and analyzing the performance of RPOs since 2002.  There can be significant ROI when outsourcing #recruitment services when you:


  • Don’t have time or have a spike in hiring needs
  • Have a Confidential Search
  • Lack of expertise to fill a position and want to deploy your recruiters for core positions
  • Need competitive intelligence

I have not seen any evidence through my research that an RPO can outperform a properly funded, well managed internal recruitment organization.  


Now before I continue, I want to make a key point. “They cannot outperform a properly funded, well managed internal recruitment organization”.


On too many occasions, I came across an organization that engaged an RPO and when I would ask them why they decided to engage them, and they often would say. . . “because our internal team was not getting the job done”.  


Analyzing the situation further, I found that recruiters were managing 50-100+ requisitions at any given time. They were not investing in recruitment marketing strategies and not efficiently managing the process. So rather than fix their internal strategy, they would outsource at MORE cost with hopes for a better solution.  




Here are some insights as to why I don’t think traditional RPO solutions are usually the best solution:


To get the right cost, RPOs usually hire inexperienced, low wage recruiters – Remember the old cliché “If it sounds too good to be true, maybe it isn’t true”? 


At the price point most RPO’s charge (4-7% of salary), they must create a very low cost of the delivery solution. Most RPO #recruiters are very entry-level and get paid a low wage. Many use offshore recruitment solutions. In either case, they are usually not Expert Recruiters performing at the Top of their Profession (see an article on this topic on our site – www.roguesearch.com). This can provide a variety of performance issues including the inability to recruit top talent for difficult to fill positions, poor candidate experience, and poor hiring manager experience.


The RPO solution is built to fill the 70% of positions that are easy to fill, not the 30% that are difficult and critical to fill – Because of the cost of service, RPO recruiters usually cannot recruit top talent for difficult to fill positions and/or don’t invest the time to fill these positions (because they are too hard to fill for the low fee %). The RPO recruiters fill the easy to fill positions (which you probably could have done internally) and the difficult to fill positions stay open! Lean Human Capital has been benchmarking Healthcare Recruitment performance for over 10 years (link). They have found that about 70% of positions that are easy to fill usually get filled in 23 +/-days. The 30% that are difficult to fill take over 120 days (4 months). We find this same type of performance consistent with #RPO solutions.


An ‘Outsourced contractor’ preaching . . . “come join our team” – This one is personal to me. 


I am a 100% believer that hiring top talent is the most important “core” job of any organization. It should be personal. Most of us spend more time with our co-workers than we do with family and friends at times 😊. So, to have an “outsourced” worker boast about why it is so great to join the “family” when they technically don’t seem a bit strange to me. But maybe this is just me 😊.


As mentioned, outsourcing recruitment should be a part of your #recruitment strategy as outlined above. 


But to outsource your entire recruitment function (or big chunks of it) to an RPO probably isn’t! We have no evidence that this solution outperforms a properly funded, well managed internal team with respect to the quality of service, speed, costs, or quality of hire.

#RogueSearch #Business #Organizations #Leadership


Please share and Follow us on social media or Contact RogueSearch below…thanks!


Let's Have Conversation

 If you have a Confidential Search.

 You need to Fill a Critical Position ASAP but you don’t have the resources or time to do it.

 The position is so Unique, that it makes sense to dedicate internal resources to filling it.

 You are seeking Neutral Competitive Intelligence on your specific labor market.

Share on linkedin
Share on twitter
Share on facebook